Este site utiliza cookies

Dados necessários para melhorar nosso serviço e personalizar a sua experiência.

  • Home
  • Blog
  • CONJUR highlights request signed by Eduardo Maneira for Carf to revoke restrictions on lawyer hearings

The website Legal Consultant reported that the Brazilian Bar Association sent a letter to the Administrative Council of Tax Appeals (Carf), to request the revocation of the limitations on lawyers' hearings with the body's advisors in drawn processes. The report highlights that the document is signed by Dr. Eduardo Maneira, who chairs the entity's Special Tax Law Commission, together with the president of the OAB, Felipe Santa Cruz.

OAB requests revocation of restrictions on lawyer hearings at Carf

October 22, 2021, 6:38 pm

By José Higídio

Last Tuesday (19/10), the Federal Council of the OAB sent a letter to the Administrative Council of Tax Appeals (Carf) to request the revocation of the limitations on hearings of lawyers with counselors in drawn cases.

A Carf ordinance last Friday (15/10) regulated hearings in the council and restricted the scheduling of these hearings to just one counselor, who must necessarily be the rapporteur of the process or the president of the class.

In the document sent to Carf, the president of CFOAB, Felipe Santa Cruz, and the president of the Special Commission on Tax Law, Eduardo Maneira, emphasize that it is essential to guarantee the parties access to all the advisors who make up the judging panel of the administrative process.

OAB Nacional highlights that the ordinance creates an unnecessary prior permission and convergence of the agenda of at least three advisors for the hearing to take place with a counselor who is not the rapporteur or the president.

“Such rules only serve to limit and hinder hearings”, says the letter. The restrictions would violate the right to defense and the prerogatives of the legal profession, in addition to not being supported by any normative act.

Santa Cruz and Maneira remember that the Advocacy Statute brings the right of the lawyer to address the magistrates directly and move freely through rooms and offices of judging bodies, even without an appointment. With the Covid-19 crisis, it would be necessary to guarantee the same rights for virtual hearings.

“Hearings with counselors cannot, under any circumstances, be seen as mere concessive acts or acts of benevolence on the part of Carf, since judicial provision under the terms of the law is a duty that obliges the public authorities and individual rights that assist the parties”, they emphasize.

In addition to being illegal, the prohibition of scheduling appointments with other counselors would not be reasonable within Carf's own procedural dynamics. The obligation for the rapporteur and the president to participate in as many hearings as necessary would overload their agendas, “without any practical benefit”.

Finally, the ordinance rule would also prevent hearings with a counselor representing civil society, in cases where the rapporteur is a representative of the National Treasury.

Click aqui to read the letter


José Higídio is a reporter for the magazine Consultor Jurídica.

Legal Consultant Magazine, October 22, 2021

https://www.conjur.com.br/2021-out-22/oab-revogacao-restricoes-audiencias-carf

See other related news stories



Split payment vira disputa eleitoral; mas como de fato o mecanismo vai funcionar?
Press

Split payment vira disputa eleitoral; mas como de fato o mecanismo vai funcionar?

October 20, 2026

O split payment, sistema de apuração e recolhimento automático de impostos que será implementado com a reforma tributária, se tornou recentemente um tema em disputa na polarização eleitoral

Aumento da base do ICMS pode se tornar a primeira grande disputa da reforma tributária
Press

Aumento da base do ICMS pode se tornar a primeira grande disputa da reforma tributária

October 1, 2026

A Emenda Constitucional n° 32, que abriu caminho para a reforma tributária do consumo, e a LC 227, a segunda mais importante que regulamentou o novo sistema, determinam expressamente que o novo IS (Imposto Seletivo) entra na base de cálculo...

Inheritance: how to find out if there are debts to pay and how to negotiate?
Press

Inheritance: how to find out if there are debts to pay and how to negotiate?

July 29, 2026

Inheritance: how to find out if there are debts to be paid and how to negotiate? July 29, 2026 By Fabiana Holtz Image: Freepik São Paulo – The discussion about the division of an inheritance (also called (estate) always raises a noisy and often...

Smaller ISS increases legal security for bank discounts
Press

Smaller ISS increases legal security for bank discounts

July 6, 2026

ICMS on what was not charged: the mistake of treating loyalty as a condition
Articles

ICMS on what was not charged: the mistake of treating loyalty as a condition

June 9, 2026

Reform threatens to raise water bills
Press

Reform threatens to raise water bills

June 1, 2026

Contato

Fale conosco


Preencha o formulário para falar com nossa equipe ou ligue, agora mesmo, para o escritório mais próximo!

Cidades

Rio de janeiro

Rio de janeiro

Av. Presidente Wilson, 231, 25° andar, Centro

(21) 2222-9008
São Paulo

São Paulo

Rua Professor Atílio de Innocenti, 165, 13º andar, Itaim Bibi

(11) 3062-2607
Brasília

Brasília

SHIS QL 08, Conjunto 01, Casa 11, Lago Sul

(61) 3224-2627
Belo Horizonte

Belo Horizonte

Av. Getúlio Vargas, 671, 13º andar, Funcionários

(31) 3190-0480